Support
  1. Search
  2. Near
New York Yellow Pages > Italian Restaurant > Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019 map
Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria Mojo 3/ 5
54
%
Vote For Us

Reviews (84)
Sort by:
Most Trusted
Newest
Recommended
Not Recommended
Helpful
Customer Ratings
5 Star:
(40)
4 Star:
(18)
3 Star:
(6)
2 Star:
(3)
1 Star:
(6)
First To Vote
RHepler
Citysearch User

Citysearch User

Sunday, January 18, 2009
Rating:
 
Value:
 
Service:
 
Quality:
 
My Absolute Favorite Pizza in NYC by Kristen Y. at InsiderPages
At my job, we order from Angelo's as often as we can. If we're working late and want a special treat, if it's someone's birthday, if it's especially cold out. We had one day where we ordered Angelo's twice! Their crust is thin, but substantial. The sauce is thick, fresh and tangy and all of their toppings are also fresh cut. You will not find a canned mushroom on an Angelo's pizza. They also make a great vegetable pizza with no cheese for the lactose-intolerant among us. Their salads are also delicious. The house dressing is light and flavorful.
Angelo's is my absolute favorite pizza.

Read more at newyork.citysearch.com
Recommended: Yes
dieselpr

dieselpr

Sunday, August 12, 2007
Rating:
 
Value:
 
Service:
 
Quality:
 
Freshest pizza, best in Midtown
You can taste the freshness of the ingredients used to make the pizzas in this Midtown restaurant. Although the location is convenient to some hotels it is somewhat out of the way for other things you may be doing, and the ambiance is nothing to write home about. I must stress however that the pizza sauce is better than Lombardi's, and arguably the crust might be too. Taste them both and decide for yourself.

Read more at newyork.citysearch.com
Pros: Pizza
Cons: Location, no refills on soda
Recommended: Yes
jess

jess

Thursday, July 12, 2007
Rating:
 
Value:
 
Service:
 
Quality:
 
:(
My boyfriend and I live in the neighborhood and have been impressed by the fact that every time we walked by, the restaurant was packed. So I decided to try it out with some ...

Read more at www.menupages.com
Recommended: Yes
Kim

Kim

Tuesday, May 29, 2007
Rating:
 
Value:
 
Service:
 
Quality:
 
It's still one of the best hidden gems!
If it's busy, expect not to be attended to too much, but if you want a quiet, quaint - WONDERFUL italian pizza place and restaurant - this is it! We come back EVERYTIME we visit ...

Read more at www.menupages.com
Recommended: Yes
adabada79

adabada79

Sunday, April 29, 2007
Rating:
 
Value:
 
Service:
 
Quality:
 
Best Pizza in NYC
My husband and I just went to Angelo's Pizza last night! It was phenomenal! I dare say it was just as good or even better than Patsy's or John's! The service was great. We were in and out in a half an hour. The restaurant was clean and welcoming. We would come back without a doubt! I'm actually craving the pizza as I'm typing this review:)

Read more at newyork.citysearch.com
Pros: The pizza!
Cons: None
Recommended: Yes
1 3 4 5
Loading Map...
Business Details on Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

Tags:

Categories:

Phone Numbers:
Primary Phone: (212) 333-4333